Referral Agency vs. Home Care Agency
Understanding the true cost of care begins with one simple question.
This comprehensive guide reveals the hidden costs, legal responsibilities, and critical questions that determine which option truly provides the best protection for your family.
When San Diego families first begin researching home care, the options can feel overwhelming. Caregiver referral services promise lower rates. Domestic referral agencies offer convenience. Licensed home care agencies appear more expensive.
But one question changes everything — Who is the employer?
After helping hundreds of local families navigate this decision, we’ve seen how this single factor affects everything: surprise expenses, legal liability, emergency coverage, and overall peace of mind.
Understanding your three main options.
Choosing the right path requires knowing what you’re truly signing up for. Each model carries its own structure, responsibility, and risk.
Option 1: Caregiver referral services (the matchmaker model)
Full independece mean full responsibility — every detail rests in your hands.
Referral services connect you with independent caregivers for a flat fee, typically between $2,500 and $5,000. You pay the finder’s fee, interview and select the caregiver, and from that moment forward, you are the employer.
You and the caregiver negotiate wages directly — the referral service doesn’t set or manage rates. You are responsible for payroll, taxes, workers’ compensation, and following all federal and state employment laws. You supervise day-to-day performance, handle scheduling, and manage any terminations or replacements yourself.
This model offers independence but carries full legal and administrative responsibility.
Option 2: Domestic referral agencies (the middleman model)
A referral agency connects you with caregivers — but you remain the employer, with full responsibility for taxes and coverage.
Domestic referral agencies also match families with caregivers but usually skip the large upfront fee. Instead, you pay an hourly rate that includes both the caregiver’s wage and the agency’s markup. Despite that, you remain the legal employer with all the same responsibilities as a direct hire.
You’re still accountable for payroll, insurance, taxes, and compliance with California labor laws. The agency serves mainly as a facilitator — not as the employer of record — leaving management, supervision, and liability in your hands.
Option 3: Licensed home care agencies (the full-service model)
The all-inclusive model that delivers peace of mind, professional oversight, and trusted care — all in one place.
Licensed home care agencies, such as All Heart Home Care, operate differently. The agency is the caregiver’s employer. Caregivers are W-2 employees, not independent contractors. We handle all hiring, training, supervision, and scheduling. Insurance, payroll compliance, and backup coverage are built in.
This model offers predictable, all-inclusive pricing and complete protection for your family. You receive professional oversight, guaranteed backup care, and no employer liability — freeing you to focus on what truly matters: your loved one’s well-being.
A family’s story: when the math became clear.
“We were quoted $25 an hour by a referral service versus $37 an hour from All Heart. It seemed like an obvious choice until we used All Heart’s cost calculator. After adding payroll taxes, workers’ comp, liability insurance, and a payroll service, we were actually paying $33 an hour — plus all the management headaches. The $4 difference for professional supervision, guaranteed coverage, and zero liability? Total no-brainer. Sometimes you don’t realize how much stress you’re carrying until it’s gone.”
— A grateful son in Rancho Bernardo
Five reality checks every family should consider.
1. Employment law compliance.
Becoming the employer means every rule and regulation now falls on you.
When you are the employer, you must handle all wage and labor requirements — including minimum wage compliance, overtime pay, paid sick leave, proper breaks, quarterly tax filings, and workers’ compensation coverage. Missing a single compliance requirement can result in fines or legal exposure.
2. Replacement costs add up quickly.
What looks affordable at first often becomes costly once reality sets in.
Caregiver turnover is common in private or referral arrangements. Each time you replace someone, you may face new finder’s fees, additional search time, and gaps in care. Families often end up paying multiple referral fees within months, tripling their original cost.
3. Emergency coverage becomes your responsibility.
When a private caregiver calls out, the stress of coverage falls on you - not the agency.
If your caregiver calls in sick or can’t arrive, coverage is entirely on you. Families often scramble to rearrange schedules or miss work to fill the gap. Licensed agencies, by contrast, maintain trained backup caregivers for these situations, ensuring care continues seamlessly.
4. Performance management gets personal.
Managing people isn't just paperwork — it's personal. When care happens at home, every conflict or misstep feels closer to the heart.
Private hiring means you must directly manage performance issues, personality conflicts, and training needs. Without professional mediation or HR support, difficult conversations become emotionally charged — especially when the caregiver works in your home and supports someone you love.
5. Legal liability follows the employer.
The moment you hire privately, you assume full responsibility for what happens during care.
If an incident occurs during care — from injury to alleged theft — the employer is legally responsible. Insurance may or may not cover the event, and referral services carry no liability for caregiver actions. With an agency, that liability is shifted away from you and managed under full insurance coverage.
How to choose the right option for your family.
Choose caregiver referral or domestic referral services if you:
Understanding your comfort level, time, and priorities helps you decide whether direct hire or professional agency care is the right fit for your family.
- Want maximum control over hiring decisions.
- Are comfortable managing payroll, taxes, and compliance.
- Have time to oversee scheduling, performance, and training.
- Can handle emergencies and coverage gaps independently.
Keep in mind that while these options may appear more affordable upfront, true costs increase once taxes, insurance, and management time are factored in.
Choose a licensed home care agency if you:
Choosing a licensed agency mean your family gains professional support, built-in protection, and peace of mind with every visit.
- Prefer professional oversight and care coordination.
- Want guaranteed coverage with backup caregivers.
- Value predictable, all-inclusive pricing.
- Want to avoid legal and employer liability.
- Appreciate a professional buffer for difficult conversations.
Red flags for any option:
- No workers’ compensation coverage.
- Unlicensed or uninsured operations.
- No clear backup plan for caregiver absences.
- Unclear or changing fee structures.
- Poor communication during screening.
- Refusal to provide references or credentials.
What makes All Heart Home Care different?
As a licensed home care agency in San Diego, we know that choosing home care is about more than finding someone to help with daily tasks. It’s about ensuring safety, professionalism, and peace of mind through every step of care.
Professional standards:
Our caregivers undergo comprehensive background checks, skills assessments, and ongoing training. We maintain active care supervision, communicate regularly with families, and adapt care plans as needs evolve.
Reliable coverage:
We provide trained backup caregivers for sick days and vacations, ensuring consistency and no gaps in service. Scheduling and coordination are handled by our professional team, not by families scrambling at the last minute.
Legal protection:
All Heart Home Care carries full workers’ compensation and liability coverage, maintaining total compliance with state and federal labor laws. We handle any performance issues or documentation needs professionally and discreetly.
Peace of mind:
You’ll have one point of contact for all care coordination, professional resolution of any issues, and smooth transitions when changes arise. We take care of the logistics so you can focus on your loved one — not the stress of managing employment.
Need assistance with comparison calculations?
If you’d like a personal walkthrough, call All Heart Home Care™ at (619) 736-4677 for a no-pressure consultation. We’ll help you evaluate which path offers the best protection and long-term sustainability for your San Diego family — even if that choice isn’t us.
Because peace of mind should never come with surprise bills or employment headaches.
Cost calculator comparison worksheet.
Don’t guess at the real expenses. Our Private Hire Cost Calculator shows precisely what you’ll pay with each option — including the hidden costs that catch families off guard.
Weekly Schedule
| Day | Input Mode | Shift 1 Start | Shift 1 End | Shift 2 Start | Shift 2 End | Total Hours |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total Hours This Week |
Rates & Comparison
| Model | Reg Hrs | OT Hrs | Weekly Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Caregiver Referral Services | |||
| Domestic Referral Agency | |||
| All Heart Home Care | |||
| Total Hours |
| Effective $/Hour (Monthly) | Caregiver Referral Services | Domestic Referral Agency | All Heart Home Care |
|---|---|---|---|
Cost Breakdown (Monthly)
| Cost Component | Caregiver Referral Services | Domestic Referral Agency | All Heart Home Care |
|---|
Monthly Cost Chart
Employer Costs (2025, CA)
Estimated Cost Impact
| Weekly | Monthly (4.333×) | |
|---|---|---|
| % Burden on Wages | ||
| Liability | $100.00 | |
| Payroll Service | $650.00 | |
| Total Employer Costs | $750.00 |
Average Rates Guide (2025, CA)
| Category | Average Rate | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| FICA (Social Security + Medicare) | 7.65% | 6.2% SS + 1.45% Medicare; wage cap applies to SS. |
| Unemployment Insurance (UI) | 3.4% (new employers) | CA EDD; first $7,000 wages/employee; rate varies over time. |
| Workers’ Compensation | 1.50–2.50% of wages | Caregiver/home health class; confirm with your carrier. |
| Liability Insurance | $50–$150/month | Household employer policy; homeowners often exclude employment injuries. |
| Payroll Service Fee (CPA/Accountant) | $650–$1700/month | Household employer payroll & filings; per-employee fees may apply. |
| Expected Caregiver Turnover | 3-6 Months | High turnover; dependent on agreed wages |
Private caregiver vs. home care agency blogs.
Navigating the choice between hiring a private caregiver and working with a professional agency can be overwhelming. Our blog offers clear, expert insights comparing both options—helping you understand costs, risks, and legal responsibilities. Explore the articles below to make an informed decision about the best care solution for your family.
How Home Care Agencies Protect You from Wage Claims & Employment Audits in California
Caring for an aging loved one at home is incredibly rewarding, but it also brings legal responsibilities that many families may not anticipate. In California, particularly in San
Top 5 Mistakes Families Make When Hiring Private Caregivers in San Diego, CA
Hiring a private in-home caregiver for an aging parent is one of the most significant decisions families must make. As adult children caring for senior loved ones, it’s
Is a Private Caregiver Really Cheaper? Understanding the Hidden Costs
Many families in San Diego and throughout California assume that hiring a private caregiver will cost less than working with a home care agency. This assumption makes sense
Get started with your free in-home care consultation.
Share a few details about your current situation, and we’ll schedule a complimentary phone consultation to understand your needs. Together, we’ll design a personalized home care plan that supports your comfort, independence, and peace of mind — so you can comfortably age gracefully in your own home.